[Ovmsdev] VW e-Up read/poll via OBD is working

[Soko]

Heya,

I'm back from my 2 hr VCDS session... not satisfying at all...

*Car-off polling issue:*
VCDS lists me 19 ECUs (with the ignition on) which includes 09 
"Zentralelektrik" (which Michael recommended), 19 "Diagnosteinterface" 
and 61 "Batterieregelung" which stay responsive for a period of time 
after ignition is off. All other are not responsive no more with no 
ignition...
But: Once the car is locked not a single ECU is responding :( . So there 
is nothing to poll which will respond in any state of the car.
The only option is the +12V on pin 1. _Is pin 1 somehow connected to 
OVMS via the standard OBD adapter?_

*Sniffing VCDS (+CarScanner App) commands:*
Here I'm somehow confused now. I've tried to sniff the header/txid of 
ECU 61 (Betterieregelung) as the list of sharkcow hasn't it listed yet. 
It seems that the header is not transmitted, neither in VCDS nor in 
CarScanner. Only the PID goes to the OBD port. To understand the 
transmissions I've tried in CarScanner to swap between two 
dashboards/value-readings. One for SoC (=22 02 8C) of ECU 8C 
(header=7E5) outside-temp (=22 F4 46) of ECU 01 (header=7E0).
I couldn't find any 7E5 or 7E0 in the sniffed data!? Why? How is the ECU 
addressed then? I've also think of any rule to get from the ECU number 
(i.e. 8C, 01) to the header, but couldn't find any...

*Scan for OBD devices:*
Thanks for the info & details Michael. But is there a chance that I'll 
find an OBD device which VCDS doesn't know about (or doesn't list in the 
software)?
If yes: Can I somehow put this manual request in C++ code instead of 
using the shell? Then I don't have to type this manually 256 times (by 
using a loop) ;)
Also, is there a typo in your email? You write "...sent to ID 700, 
type..." but the command says "79b" and later you write "...there is a 
device listening at 79b...". So is ID 700 the device 79b or did you mean 
ID 79B?

thx for you patience with me

Soko

On 31.07.2020 14:09, Michael Balzer wrote:
> Soko,
>
> you don't need to use the poller to scan for OBD devices. You can 
> simply do manual transmissions and look for responses.
>
> To send a manual request, simply use the can tx command. Example:
>
> OVMS# can can1 tx standard 79b 02 01 00 00 00 00 00 00
>
> This means: 2 byte OBD request sent to ID 700, type 01 = get current 
> data, from PID 00. PID 00 is supposed (OBD-II) to reply with a four 
> byte bitset of the device's PIDs 01-20 (hex) support.
>
> Send this with can logging enabled without filters, so you can see all 
> responses. A response could look like this:
>
> V (591792) canlog-monitor: 1596194327.716686 1R11 7BB 03 7f 01 11 00 
> 00 00 00
>
> This tells you:
>
>   * there is a device listening at 79b, which answers at 7bb -- nice!
>   * it probably talks ISO-TP -- nice!
>   * it  won't allow you to do this request in it's default session: 7F
>     = serviceNotSupportedInActiveSession
>
> OK, let's try to change the session (command 10) to the ISO 14229 
> standard "extendedDiagnosticSession" (value 03):
>
> V (2085712) canlog-monitor: 1596195821.642256 1T11 79B 02 10 03 00 00 
> 00 00 00
> V (2085722) canlog-monitor: 1596195821.659737 1R11 7BB 03 7f 10 12 00 
> 00 00 00
>
> No luck. You can now begin trying all possible session codes. Or, in 
> my case, I already know the device uses C0 ;-)
>
> V (2095662) canlog-monitor: 1596195831.598560 1T11 79B 02 10 c0 00 00 
> 00 00 00
> V (2095672) canlog-monitor: 1596195831.609308 1R11 7BB 02 50 c0 00 00 
> 00 00 00
>
> We're logged in -- nice! :-)
>
> Let's try the PID read again (do this within 60 seconds or the session 
> will log out, unless you send a "tester present" frame):
>
> V (2530842) canlog-monitor: 1596196266.780867 1T11 79B 02 01 00 00 00 
> 00 00 00
> V (2530862) canlog-monitor: 1596196266.797961 1R11 7BB 03 7f 01 11 00 
> 00 00 00
>
> Still no luck. So this tells you, the device does not support standard 
> OBD-II PIDs. How about a UDS DTC request (19)?
>
> V (3034142) canlog-monitor: 1596196770.085839 1T11 79B 02 19 01 ff 00 
> 00 00 00
> V (3034162) canlog-monitor: 1596196770.103517 1R11 7BB 03 7f 19 12 00 
> 00 00 00
>
> No luck. Let's try command 21 (read enhanced data by 8 bit PID) at PID 
> 00 next:
>
> V (2737632) canlog-monitor: 1596196473.567437 1T11 79B 02 21 00 00 00 
> 00 00 00
> V (2737712) canlog-monitor: 1596196473.649927 1R11 7BB 03 7f 21 12 00 
> 00 00 00
>
> Nope… maybe PID 01?
>
> V (2744182) canlog-monitor: 1596196480.120911 1T11 79B 02 21 01 00 00 
> 00 00 00
> V (2744262) canlog-monitor: 1596196480.203461 1R11 7BB 10 34 61 01 13 
> 88 13 83
>
> Houston, we've got a response :-)
>
> You would now check if this response is a single or multi frame type, 
> then try to get all data and then try to map the data to something you 
> would expect to be stored in that device.
>
> For the standard UDF commands, you will need a copy of the ISO 14229 
> standard.
>
> Regards,
> Michael
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openvehicles.com/pipermail/ovmsdev/attachments/20200731/72393095/attachment.html>